Dispute Resolution and Consumer Rights
Poor workmanship, abandoned jobs and billing disputes happen. Knowing your rights and the correct process to follow can save you thousands and recover your position quickly.
What to Do If a Tradie Does Poor Work
Document everything immediately
Photograph the defective work before doing anything else. Capture date-stamped photos from multiple angles. Keep all written communications, contracts, invoices and payment records. This evidence is critical if you proceed to a formal dispute.
Contact the tradie in writing
Send a written notice (email is fine) to the tradie describing the specific defects, referencing your contract, and requesting rectification within a reasonable timeframe (typically 14 business days for minor defects, longer for major work). Keep the tone factual and professional.
Get an independent assessment
If the tradie disputes that there is a defect, engage an independent trade professional or building inspector to assess the work and provide a written report. For building work, a licensed building inspector can provide this. Their report carries weight in any formal dispute.
Attempt informal resolution
Many disputes are resolved by direct negotiation once the tradie understands you are serious and have documentation. Offer them the opportunity to rectify the work before you escalate. Keep records of all communication attempts.
Contact the relevant Fair Trading office
If direct negotiation fails, contact your state's Fair Trading or consumer protection authority. In most states, they offer free or low-cost conciliation services that can resolve disputes without going to tribunal. This is the required first step before tribunal in many jurisdictions.
Escalate to a tribunal if needed
If conciliation fails, you can file an application with your state's civil and administrative tribunal (NCAT, VCAT, QCAT, etc). These tribunals are designed for consumers and do not require a lawyer. Filing fees are modest and hearings are usually scheduled within weeks.
Fair Trading Contacts by State
Each state and territory has a dedicated consumer protection body. Start here for free advice, conciliation and complaint lodgement.
NSW Fair Trading
Phone: 13 32 20
Consumer Affairs Victoria
Phone: 1300 558 181
Queensland Building and Construction Commission (QBCC)
Phone: 139 333
Consumer and Business Services SA
Phone: 131 882
Consumer Protection WA
Phone: 1300 304 054
Consumer, Building and Occupational Services (CBOS)
Phone: 1300 654 499
NT Consumer Affairs
Phone: 1800 019 319
Access Canberra
Phone: 13 22 81
When Can You Withhold Payment?
Important: Withholding payment incorrectly can expose you to legal action. Always seek written advice before withholding money owed under a contract.
Work is incomplete: You are generally entitled to withhold the portion of payment that relates to incomplete stages of work, provided your contract specifies staged payments tied to milestones.
Defective work identified before final payment: If defects are identified before final payment is due, you may have grounds to withhold the final payment pending rectification. Document defects thoroughly and notify the tradie in writing before the payment due date.
Do not withhold all payment for minor defects: Withholding total payment for minor defects when most of the work is complete may give the tradie grounds to pursue you for the full amount. Withhold only a reasonable sum proportionate to the defect.
Progress payments already paid cannot be reclaimed unilaterally: If you have already paid for a stage that is defective, you must pursue a refund through formal channels rather than withholding future payments that relate to other stages.
Building Inspectors and Defect Reports
🏗️
When to Hire a Building Inspector
A licensed building inspector can assess workmanship against the Building Code of Australia and relevant Australian Standards. Engage one when the tradie disputes your defect claims, or when the defects involve structural, waterproofing or safety-related work.
📄
What a Defect Report Covers
A formal defect report itemises each defect, references the applicable standard that has been breached, and provides an estimated rectification cost. This report is your primary tool for negotiations, tribunal hearings and insurance claims.
⏱️
Defect Liability Periods
Most states impose statutory defect liability periods on residential building work, typically ranging from 6 months (minor defects) to 6 years (major structural defects). These periods run from the date of practical completion. Check your state's specific legislation.
📱
Documenting Your Defects
Photograph defects with a ruler or reference object for scale. Record the date with your phone's camera metadata on. Create a written log of when defects appeared or were discovered. Save any relevant weather or event records that may explain when damage occurred.
How to Leave an Effective Review
Honest, detailed reviews protect other homeowners and hold tradies accountable. Here is how to write a review that has maximum impact.
Be specific, not general
"The plasterer left visible joins on the ceiling and did not sand around the cornice" is far more useful than "bad work". Specific details help others understand exactly what happened.
Include the timeline
Note when the job was booked, when it started, when it was meant to finish and when it actually finished. Delays and no-shows are important context for other readers.
Describe your attempts to resolve it
Mention whether you contacted the tradie about issues and how they responded. A tradie who tried to rectify problems but fell short is different from one who ignored all contact.
Avoid personal attacks
Reviews focused on the work and the process rather than personal attacks are more credible and are less likely to be removed for violating platform policies.
Mention what was done well
If aspects of the job were good, say so. Balanced reviews are more trustworthy and help other homeowners understand the full picture.
Keep it factual and verifiable
Only include statements you can support with evidence. Factual accuracy protects you from any defamation concerns and makes your review far more useful.
Understanding State Tribunals
Each state and territory operates a civil and administrative tribunal for resolving consumer and building disputes. They are designed to be accessible to everyday Australians without needing a lawyer.
Do I need a lawyer?
In most cases, no. Tribunals are designed for self-represented applicants. Complex cases involving significant amounts may benefit from legal advice, but the process itself is designed to be accessible without it.
How much does it cost to apply?
Filing fees for consumer and building disputes are typically modest. Most states charge between $50 and $200 depending on the claim value. Concession holders usually pay a reduced fee.
How long does it take?
First directions hearings are usually listed within 4 to 8 weeks of filing. Final hearings may be 3 to 6 months away. Some tribunals offer mediation, which can resolve matters faster.
What outcomes can a tribunal order?
Tribunals can order a tradie to rectify work, pay you a sum of money to cover rectification costs, refund deposits or pay compensation. They can also dismiss your application if your case is not established.
What if the tradie does not comply with an order?
Tribunal orders are enforceable through the courts. If a tradie ignores an order, you can apply for enforcement action through the relevant court, which may include seizure of assets or garnishing income.
Avoid Disputes by Hiring Right
The best dispute is one that never happens. Start with verified, licensed tradies who have genuine reviews from homeowners like you.